How to Address the Budget Squeeze Without Raising Taxes
Episode 104
Recorded live at the Harvard Kennedy School at our Project on Municipal Innovation convening, Chris Morrill (CEO of GFOA) and Stephen Goldsmith reveal how cities can stop treating budgets as constraint documents and start using them as tools for building trust, discovering hidden revenue, and making smarter fiscal choices. From program-based budgeting to AI-informed fee analysis to asset-based revenue strategies, hear practical approaches that have increased revenue for cities without increasing taxes.
In this episode, you'll learn:
- How to shift your internal budget conversation from "departments compete" to "programs solve problems"
- Where billions of dollars in revenue are hiding and how to audit your assets to unlock them
- How segmented pricing and AI actually help low-income residents while increasing collections
- Why your budget needs to tell a story about trust and fairness, and how to use behavioral science and digital tools to get better community input
Listen here, or wherever you get your podcasts. The following is a transcript of the conversation.
Betsy Gardner:
Hi, and welcome to the Data Smart City Pod. This is Betsy Gardner, senior editor at Data-Smart City Solutions at the Bloomberg Center for Cities at Harvard University and producer of this podcast. We have a really special episode for you today. This is a fireside chat, recorded live with our usual host, Professor Stephen Goldsmith, and Chris Morrill, Executive Director and CEO of the Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA). They were speaking at our recent Project on Municipal Innovation convening, which brings together chiefs of staff and senior city officials from the 40 largest U.S. cities.
During this conversation, Chris and Steve explore the fiscal pressures cities are facing—from revenue challenges and state preemption to workforce costs—and dig into practical tools and strategies for building fiscal resilience. We’re excited to share this moment from the convening; you might hear some background noise during the panel, but we hope you enjoy this exclusive content. Thanks for listening.
Stephen Goldsmith:
We're going to talk with Chris, executive director of GFOA, and we're going to have a little conversation with him. Let's begin with, what is GFOA?
Chris Morrill:
Thanks, Steve. So Government Finance Officers Association of the US and Canada was founded in 1906 as part of Teddy Roosevelt's Good Government Movement to try to reduce corruption in government. And anybody who works in government finance, cities, counties, states, schools, special districts are members. We have about 38,000 members now, and it's a jurisdiction-wide membership. So all of you can go to gfoa.org/join, put your name in, and you're automatically a member because your jurisdictions are members. Use all of our materials.
Stephen Goldsmith:
And you're a retired city manager?
Chris Morrill:
Yes. I was assistant city manager in Savannah, Georgia, and budget director, and then city manager in Roanoke, Virginia. Did a little work in Ukraine, and then I worked with the Ministry of Finance in South Africa to set up their local government finance system post-apartheid.
Stephen Goldsmith:
Well, congratulations on being a city manager. It's not as good as being a mayor.
Chris Morrill:
[laughter] No, of course not.
Stephen Goldsmith:
Might be second or third best. So you did a survey of 35,000 finance professionals. What's changed in the last couple years at the local level that would be helpful for these folks to know about?
Chris Morrill:
Yeah, it's been interesting. You all are living it, but what we're finding is that it's just not one thing on the revenue side or one thing on the expense side. We're seeing increasing costs, workforce issues, at the same time that you're dealing with more state preemption caps on revenue, trying to eliminate revenue than we've ever seen before.
And so you're dealing with both of those at the same time that you're dealing with challenges of cybersecurity and other stuff. And so the way we're looking at this, in the past, you've had a crisis like COVID or the global financial crisis where you have a shock to the system, you can rally everybody around it. Here, it feels like more like a slow squeeze. And so it's almost harder to get people to rally around big solutions that you may have to put into place. That's why we've really been looking at new tools and resources that cities, counties, local governments can use to deal when there isn't that shock. It's just that ongoing crisis. And I think the squeeze is just going to get worse.
Stephen Goldsmith:
Across the country, are the problems...every city's different, but just, are they more generally revenue problems or spending problems?
Chris Morrill:
I would say probably the more acute ones are the revenue problems. So what we're hearing in general from our members is that revenues just aren't growing to keep up pace with expenditures. And then when you put on top of that, so many states, both red and blue states are looking at preemption of a lot of your abilities or really, really concerned about what's happening with property taxes. It's such a blunt instrument to cap or to exempt or to try to eliminate. And it seems like states are racing to the bottom in that.
So we are hoping, while our research has been at the national level, we just had a discussion with our board. We're going to try to partner with National Association of Counties, League of Cities, Pew Charitable Trust is really interested, and a couple states to actually step back and look at the local government revenue system.
It's pretty much based on goods and land when we know the modern economy is based on services and technology to see if we could get a couple states to really look at it and see if there's understanding the challenges of property taxes. Are there better ways that we could approach this that could become a model for other states to take on? But I think it's at state level we really have to work on.
Stephen Goldsmith:
I want to ask you about specific revenue sources, but before I do that, have you seen anybody who's effectively used the budget as a communications tool? Is it just too clumsy and, whether it's digital or otherwise, how can you tell a story with the budget?
Chris Morrill:
Yeah, I think there are some good models out there. One of the best we've seen is the Fort Worth Lab. We've done a lot around rethinking budgeting and really looking that now is the time that using technology in other ways and understanding behavioral science, we can do budgeting differently. Well, Fort Worth, they embraced all of it, really putting together the budget, the data analysis, the strategic planning folks, and then they really now talk about programs and services, not about departments.
And I think that is a key mind shift because for years the budget's been a zero-sum game. Police gets more, parks and rec gets less. And when you can move away from departments to...citizens don't say that, "I want more Public Works." They say, "I want safe streets." Well, when you're funding a safe streets program, then police works with traffic engineering, works with public works, maybe with parks and rec, and it does change the discussion and the approach.
One other point with that, and with your budget, you probably have to start with trust internally. I think a lot of your departments, you ask them about the budget, it's a black box. Fort Worth has really made sure that it is a collaborative approach across departments. And then when you have trust there, it's going to help you with the externally with the citizens also.
Stephen Goldsmith:
Anybody have any digital budget tools they use for communication purposes? Can people move around their budgets for... It used to be those tools where-
Chris Morrill:
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah... with citizens, it's like a budge game where citizens-
Stephen Goldsmith:
It's a budget game, yeah.
Chris Morrill:
... can budget their own. Yeah. And I've seen some most recent research where it shows if you do those games, they often don't want to start with a deficit because it makes them look bad. But if the reality is you have a deficit and they have to make those tough choices, they find they actually get better data out of that. I think there's one called Balancing Act and there's a new one coming out called Weigh In.
Stephen Goldsmith:
Let's talk about specific ways to raise money. So are there good examples of cities that have done comprehensive user fee analysis to see whether their user fees are properly calculated and fair?
Chris Morrill:
Yeah, I don't know that I can point to a city that's done it comprehensively, although I'm seeing a lot more, especially in the water utility area, where they're really looking at full cost pricing and then looking at strategic asset management and making sure that it's going to last into the future. And they're doing some pretty interesting stuff.
American Waterworks Association is actually going to start giving an award based on water sustainability systems. We've been working with them. And then this approach called segmented pricing. So it's used in Europe, but the idea is that parking could be water, sewer, court fees, that the current approach where you have one fee that everybody pays and then maybe in water and sore you may give some kind of discount based on level of income really doesn't work well. And so what we did piloting with Portland and working with a company that primarily through AI is looking at the delinquent fees and it was about 18% of their water fees were delinquent.
And then we found many of them were folks who were above the income levels where they gave the discount. And so what you do is using AI, they could look at their property tax payment history, they could look at where they lived and other things to right size what they would pay. So they went back to turning off water, so they did have that sanction piece, but then they would work with them on a fee that they could afford. And what happened is the revenue, the revenue stayed stable - actually went up a little bit - and they found property tax payments went up from those folks also.
Stephen Goldsmith:
I think this is a really big deal. We don't pay attention to the equitable effect of a fine. A hundred dollar fine on somebody earns $15,000 is a lot different than a $100 fine, for somebody who earns $300,000. And what Chris's partner's research shows, if you reduce the penalties, your revenues go up, not down because folks who are at the bottom end and get the fine and as the fine aggravates, their chances of paying are even less. It's like all or nothing. And so your project is a really interesting project.
Chris Morrill:
I think your point about comprehensive, to look at the fees themselves, we found in many cases, particularly in court fees, they're more expensive to collect them than it is in the revenue that they get. So it's actually a money loser for them to have these fees. So to think intelligently, and as I talked to my folks about it, if somebody wanted to pilot this, parking fees would probably be a good place to start. And it can often accelerate where somebody gets a parking ticket, they don't pay it, the fees go up, it gets to the point where they get booted, they can't drive to work. I mean, it really accelerates.
So here's just some of the findings from the Portland pilot that we have. It's this idea of small targeted discounts, but you really need AI to identify where those targeted ones are going to work and then that you continue recalibrating as you're seeing because people's behavior changes, but it really focuses on behavior. You may have those deep broad discounts based on income and you can keep those. Also, you need that enforcement piece. This really wouldn't have worked had Portland not gone back to shutting off water.
Stephen Goldsmith:
Years ago in New York, the council was arguing about water amnesties, which created a moral hazard because people who were struggling to pay and paying and others who could pay and didn't, it kind of reversed that. That led to a loan fund that the city administered, which I think is one of the things you're suggesting. So you could do this broadly. Cars are registered so you know what neighborhoods they're from. So why couldn't you do a program like this that encouraged compliance, not penalties, right?
Chris Morrill:
Yeah, no, I think you absolutely could. If you go to gfoa.org, you'll see under our Rethinking Revenue landing page that we have a research report on this. And then also we've been working with a guy named Brian Glenn, a company that's called SERVUS. So the other is putting assets to work.
We were looking at mainly at Scandinavian - and then you'll see it in some Asian countries - where they intentionally look at all of the assets that they have. You pick a topic that you want ongoing revenue to focus on. Atlanta worked on housing. We worked with Annapolis in Anne Arundel County. Theirs was sea level rise. So it's something that people can rally around. So housing was one. So Atlanta, Atlanta Public Schools and the Housing Authority worked together to identify all their land. And you have land you don't even know you have, and it probably is undervalued because you don't spend time assessing your publicly owned land.
They identified about $2.3 billion in assets out there. Then you sit back and you intentionally think, well, we may sell off some of it, but the goal is really to create an ongoing revenue stream. And so from that, they were able to identify some that they could build public housing on and reduce the cost of buying land. And then others were, they commercialized it, but they didn't sell the land, they did a lease, and then they had an ongoing revenue source that all goes back into public housing.
If you go back and look, we found Salt Lake County, they identified $10 billion worth of underused property. The next step is then you probably have some property you're using that is way underused. For example, you may be keeping your salt pile on a beautiful piece of land next to the river. And so you move the salt pile and you commercialize that. This is something that I think you could go back and work on right away.
Stephen Goldsmith:
So what are other sources of revenue that could drop from the sky that would help the budget?
Chris Morrill:
[laughs] right, too bad there's not more. I think when you look at property taxes, which is probably a major source for many of you, another thing that we looked at really working with tax-exempt landowners to really talk to them. And it wasn't just give us money, but they actually had a dialogue of the value that that nonprofit or that tax-exempt property was providing to the community, whether it's be a college or a church or something. But then they were able to negotiate payments in lieu of taxes based on what they were receiving from the city through a dialogue. And I think it made them $17 million, so, some cash. And it also built relationships so that when there's a climate change disaster or something, you have connections with all of those bases.
Stephen Goldsmith:
There's some cities that have PILOTS against their own stormwater utilities, one in Indianapolis against a quasi-government structure that's the water utility.
Chris Morrill:
Maybe just one more property tax thing too is I think there's a question about fairness. Working with the University of Chicago, we found that the assessments in particular on average are really unfair, that the bottom 10% valued properties pay twice as much in real tax rate compared to the 10% highest. Because what happens if you have a straw house and a wooden house and a brick house, the wooden house is what they go off of as the average. And it won't necessarily make you more revenue...it shouldn't cost you revenue, but I think it will deal with the fairness issue.
Stephen Goldsmith:
So what are the best set of tools that you think a city could use?
Chris Morrill:
The new approach to budgeting is called target-based budgeting. It takes the best concept of budgeting for outcomes or priority-based budgeting, but makes it a lot simpler, not as heavy a lift. So if you Google target-based budgeting GFOA, you'll see how you can do it. And it's really based on your revenue, but it creates incentives really to the behavioral science around budgeting. And so I highly recommend that. And then just one last thing. Everything that we do, we work off of our financial foundations. It's based on common pool resource theory, this Nobel Prize winning work by Elinor Ostrom around how people can use a shared resource like a shared common green space or fishery where it's everybody's incentive to possibly overdo it. So we applied that to budgeting. All the work that we do, we work on these five pillars: establish a long-term vision that values discussion, communicate that vision to rally people around, purposely build trust and open communication, design a budget process that helps build trust also, use collective decision making whenever you can.
We did that in Roanoke and at one point when we had our seventh year of budgeting, the police chief gave up a police officer position for an early childhood librarian position because he understood the impact it had on third grade level reading because he was part of those discussions. It doesn't happen very often.
And then create clear rules, have strong policies, have the discussions now about your values and the rules so when that crisis happens, you're ready to deal with it. And then the last one, really think about how everyone is not just treated fairly, but feels like they're treated fairly. And we have some really good material on procedural justice and distributive justice.
Stephen Goldsmith:
That was great, Chris. Thank you very much.
Chris Morrill:
All right. Thanks y'all. [applause]
About the Author
Betsy Gardner
Betsy Gardner is the editor of Data-Smart City Solutions and the producer of the Data-Smart City Pod. Prior to this, Betsy worked in a variety of roles in higher education, focusing on deconstructing racial and gender inequality through research, writing, and facilitation. She also researched government spending and transparency at the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy. Betsy holds a master’s degree in Urban and Regional Policy from Northeastern University, a bachelor’s degree in Art History from Boston University, and a graduate certificate in Digital Storytelling from the Harvard Extension School.