TIFs and Redevelopment
Downtowns are valued not only for their picturesque skylines, but because they are a city’s economic engine: they are a nexus of integrated infrastructure, transit, commercial corridors, and cultural and tourist attractions. These resource-rich urban centers are increasingly luring professionals and families back from the suburbs, reversing a decades-long trend. In Philadelphia, for example, where citywide population is growing for the first time in 60 years, most residential growth is occurring in Center City where 44 percent of all employment takes place.
With such a high concentration of employers, employees and infrastructure, downtown investments often yield a higher return than what can be achieved in other areas of a city. In Asheville, N.C., the dense downtown contributes 97 times more in property taxes per acre than other areas. And between 2006 and 2010, Nashville’s downtown reinvestment totaled $2.4 billion, only 15 percent of which was public funds.
So what are the different downtown redevelopment models? And how are these projects financed? To discuss these questions and others, the Harvard Kennedy School and Living Cities, Inc. convened the eleventh Project on Municipal Innovation – Advisory Group (PMI-AG). As part of this network, more than 30 leaders from America's largest and most creative cities discussed the adoption and replication of innovative ideas in urban governance. One session focused on finance tools for downtown revitalization and redevelopment, giving participating cities a forum to compare their different downtown development stories.
Every downtown story is different, and the developmental focus of a city evolves as administrations and economies change. Some cities bet on professional sports stadiums, like Minneapolis. Others capitalize on the natural landscape, like San Antonio did with its River Walk. Boston focused on its pioneering Main Streets program, Los Angeles has its motion picture cluster and Cleveland appealed to anchor institutions. The City of Vancouver amended its downtown zoning laws to support high-density residential development, which now has a return on investment five times more than the return on commercial office space. As a result of this policy, which was implemented in 1991, Vancouver boasts one of the highest residential density rates in North America.
Financing downtown development has become an art form, partially due to a national credit crunch and tightening of the terms and conditions of bank loans. Although not exhaustive, a handy matrix was distributed at the session that reviews the pros and cons of several financing tools and provides examples of cities that have successfully used each of the tools.
Indianapolis, for example, is a national leader in the use of Tax Increment Financing (TIF) districts. Tax increment bonds from the city’s first TIF in 1986 helped advance the development of an enclosed mall, which became a centerpiece of the downtown. The city’s use of TIFs has evolved with the market, focusing first on retail, then attracting suburban companies to downtown commercial offices, and now to mixed-use urban living spaces.
Over the last four years in the city’s largest TIF – spanning 1,700 acres – more than $87 million in public funds has leveraged more than $873 million in private funds. It has done so with artful combinations of funding sources, including national philanthropic funds and state funding programs like Certified Technology Park designations and applications to the Office of Community & Rural Affairs. The city is even using TIF funds to leverage revenue from privatized public goods, like parking meters and water and wastewater systems.
Deron Kintner, the city’s Deputy Mayor for Economic Development, describes TIF districts as leading to a host of win-win projects: “It has been a great tool for the city, allowing us to leverage a great diversity of private investment and get more projects completed than probably any other tool.” And whether or not a specific project is city- or private-led, he said Indianapolis evaluates its involvement based on one criterion – whether the project is transformational or catalytic.
In sum, several pieces of wisdom emerged from the session. Take stock of the city’s assets. Consult the city’s long-term plans. Determine if the city’s deficiencies are worth shoring up, like whether it needs a major league stadium or convention center to compete, or whether it will be different. After all, successful placemaking includes quality of life amenities and unique civic spaces, too.
About the Author
Stephanie Larkins
Stephanie Larkins holds an MPA from the University of Pennsylvania's Fels Institute of Government. Prior to joining the Ash Center, Stephanie crafted legislation for a Philadelphia City Councilman and researched best practices in government for the National League of Cities. Her current research interests include public finance, citizen participation and innovative management.